As Fr. Jose Eduardo Oliveira e Silva notes, infallibility is not a human privilege, but a grace granted by Christ so that the faith may not be distorted over the centuries. If you wish to understand why the Church claims to possess infallible authority in certain circumstances and how this protects—rather than limits—the freedom of the faithful, continue reading and see how truth, apostolic mission, and pastoral care are intertwined.
Infallibility as a gift received from Christ
Infallibility is grounded in the divine promise. Christ guaranteed that His Church would remain in the truth and that the Holy Spirit would guide it safely. This promise does not eliminate the humanity of pastors, but it prevents the Church, as a teaching body, from teaching error when it defines a truth of faith or morals. Infallibility is an expression of God’s fidelity, not of human perfection.
Jose Eduardo Oliveira e Silva explains that infallibility serves as a fundamental pillar of the Magisterium’s mission, ensuring that the Church preserves integrity in the transmission of the faith. The Church has been endowed with a special authority to interpret Revelation authentically and faithfully. When the Pope or an ecumenical council pronounces on a doctrine, they act as true guardians of the deposit of faith, ensuring that the Christian message remains pure and unchanged.
Such definitions do not introduce innovations, but rather preserve the truth received from the Apostles, keeping apostolic tradition alive. Infallibility therefore acts as a safeguard against erroneous interpretations that could divert the Gospel from its original essence, ensuring that the faith of the faithful is not compromised by distorted views or by theological fashions that arise over time.
The spiritual function of infallibility for the faithful
Infallibility offers the people of God firm and reliable security. According to Jose Eduardo Oliveira e Silva, amid cultural uncertainties and intense theological debates, the faithful find in the Magisterium a solid foundation on which they can rely. This gift ensures that doctrine presented as definitive not only points toward the truth, but also leads to eternal salvation.
At the same time, infallibility does not mean automatic holiness. The pastors of the Church may commit sins or personal failings; however, they are not permitted to lead the people into error when exercising the Magisterium. While impeccability refers to the absence of sin, infallibility refers to the protection of doctrine—an essential distinction for maintaining balance and avoiding unrealistic expectations regarding the Pope or the bishops.
Service to communion and unity in the Church
Infallibility preserves the unity of the faith by ensuring clarity in fundamental truths. As Fr. Jose Eduardo Oliveira e Silva affirms, when these teachings are defined precisely, the Church is protected from doctrinal divisions that could fragment it. This principle strengthens communion among the faithful, ensures the continuity of faith across generations, and provides spiritual stability in the face of the challenges proper to each era.
In this sense, infallibility in the Catholic Church manifests itself as an expression of God’s care for His people. It is a gift received from Christ and exercised by the Magisterium as a service of guardianship and guidance, offering security to the faithful and clearly distinguishing itself from the idea of impeccability. Far from imprisoning the faith, infallibility protects it, fostering trust, unity, and inner firmness in the light of God.
Author:
